…and what actually has to change
Third post in this summer’s Church Hiring Series
Impressions, feedback and scuttlebutt
This is the third post in a series on hiring and retaining singers for church music programs. If you’re catching up, the first post looked at why some singers are quietly opting out of church work, and the second traced what happens when a program loses its music staff one resignation at a time.
Most church music directors have stayed quiet since our previous installment ran, but that’s not surprising. This is a conversation that touches budgets, boards, and long-standing arrangements that nobody particularly enjoys reexamining in public. But metrics and private feedback confirm that the piece has not gone unread. There have been repeated reports that readers have shared parts of the series locally—from director to director, and sometimes church to church, and hopefully generating interesting conversations. That is the goal here.
There’s also a little rumor — unconfirmed, but from two trusted sources — that the last piece has traveled even further up the chain than the music directors, and has grabbed the notice of some regional church leaders. It fits everything else I’ve heard: this conversation isn’t limited to one region, or even one role. Decision-makers at various levels are taking a look, as well they should
What has not been quiet is the singer response. Since the last post went up, I’ve heard from working singers, independently and repeatedly, making some version of the same point: their rates for church work are relatively unchanged from where they were up to twenty years ago, while nearly everything else in their financial lives has moved considerably. That’s not an opinion or a mood. It’s arithmetic, and it’s the kind of math that leaves a big impact on a choir, even if part of that pressure seems invisible. Few churches want to lose an existing music program, and those that do will come under serious scrutiny — music puts butts in seats, and is valuable for many other reasons. (More on that in a later post.)
Many singers we’re hearing from show commitment to sacred roles, and are still finding joy in what they do. Others, or even the same ones, are doing the same work, frustrated, and prepared to name it plainly. Both reactions are worth taking at face value, and this is an excellent example of “two things can be true”. The frustration is not a threat to institutions on its own, but information about where the labor market actually sits right now. The joy is what offers a real opportunity for useful conversations, investment in the future on both sides, and
So what can directors do?
I don’t have a complete answer here, and I’d be wary of anyone who claimed to. What I’d suggest instead is treating the coming liturgical season as a period of assessment rather than a problem to close out by Advent. The directors who start paying real attention now — to how their singers are actually experiencing the job, to what their postings really ask for versus what they say — will go into next year’s planning with something most programs don’t have: specific, current information about their own situation, rather than assumptions carried over from however things have always been done.
That distinction matters because some of what needs to change is structural and slow, and some of it isn’t. Both matter, and neither substitutes for the other. But you can’t build a good multi-year plan on guesses, and this season is the time to stop guessing.
Start now — the mindset shift, not the fix…
An essential conversation
Open an actual conversation with your current staff singers, sometime soon, about how the work is going for them. Not a review, not a survey — a real conversation, initiated by the director, about what’s working and what isn’t. It can be a nice way to get to know each other at the start of a new season, and the conversation can do much to set the tone for the year and open up doors of communication. Most singers have never been asked this directly, and the absence of the question reads as indifference whether or not that’s intended. Pro tip: This conversation will probably work best without other church leadership in the room — not to shut anyone out, but so singers can speak candidly and the director isn’t managing more voices than the moment calls for.
A little review
Pull your current job listings and position descriptions and read them as a singer would. Look for vague scope, unstated expectations (holiday services, extra rehearsals, last-minute coverage), and anything that’s grown informally over time without ever being written down or compensated. Flag what needs to be clarified, even if you’re not ready to change it yet.
Take an honest inventory of what the job actually asks of a singer, beyond the notes on the page. Unusual-hour services, travel time, parking access, whether there’s a meal on a long rehearsal-and-service day — these details don’t show up in a job posting, but they show up fast in whether a singer stays. On the flip side, look at what you already offer that isn’t being advertised: a paid annual retreat where singers and volunteers actually get to know each other, flexibility around subs, anything that builds real connection rather than just compensation. If you have something good, say so — singers evaluating a position can’t weigh a perk they don’t know exists.
Resources coming
A companion worksheet on perks and considerations is in the works, and I’m using the coming weeks to gather more input before release — look for it this fall. Share your input here
The harder work
These steps are slower, and worth starting to track now even if you can’t act yet:
- Review how your own position is classified — employee versus independent contractor — against the actual laws that apply where you are. This isn’t a compliance afterthought; misclassification is a real and growing area of exposure for all business entities, including nonprofits and faith-based organizations. It’s worth involving someone who actually knows the current rules rather than relying on how it’s always been done. Check the state website, and see if there’s a savvy attorney on your board or vestry.
- Build an actual timeline for bringing compensation toward market value, even if it can’t happen in one budget cycle. A published, multi-year plan is a meaningfully different signal to a candidate than an open-ended “we’ll look into it.”
- Talk to your board about what “market value” means for your region and your denomination specifically — not what it meant when your program started, but what it means for the singers you’re actually trying to hire now.
The first list is genuinely worth doing, and doing soon. But it isn’t a substitute for the second. An organization that only ever does the easy version — better conversations, cleaner job postings — while leaving classification and compensation untouched indefinitely will find that goodwill only stretches so far. Responsible institutions look at both lists, on both timelines, and treat the first as a start rather than a finish.
And more resources
A printable version for boards and committees is coming this fall as well — if you have thoughts on what it should cover, I’d rather hear them before it’s finished than after. Share your thoughts here
To the directors already doing some version of this
Some of you reading this are already having these conversations, already reviewing your own numbers without anyone telling you to — kudos, you’re ahead of the game. For everyone else, none of this depends on getting it right all at once. One honest conversation this season is a good start. Thank you for reading this far, and best wishes for joyful growth.
A word to singers, too
Some of you reading this have left church work behind, or never tried it in the first place, for reasons that made complete sense at the time. I won’t tell you you’re wrong — every singer must decide what they will accept and where their boundaries are. But if it’s been a while since you’ve considered sacred work, it may be worth another look — not every singer needs a church job, but for the right person in the right room, it can offer something steadier and deeper than the paycheck alone. We’ll explore that more deeply as the liturgical year continues. (I’d love to hear from any of you, too.)
Previous post in series: What professional singers are actually weighing